Home -> Law Blog Directory -> Legal Commentary Blogs -> Althouse

Legal Commentary

: Althouse

What it was really like in that Chilean mine.

Surprisingly different from what I'd pictured:

The men... were not confined to the ?rescue chamber,? the size of a Manhattan studio apartment...

?They had the run of the mine,? said Jeffery H. Kravitz, acting director for technical support at the United States Mine Safety and Health Administration. With half a mile of tunnels open, he said, ?they had places to exercise and to use for waste.? One miner ran several miles a day.

?They even had a sort of waterfall they could take a shower under,? Mr. Kravitz said. ?They requested shampoo, and shaved for their families.?

Also, fresh air was pumped in, so asphyxiation was never a danger.... The air was nearly 90 degrees and humid, but it contained about 20 percent oxygen, like outside air. The men dug three wells, and had potable water....

Eventually, all sorts of comfort goods were going down three narrow tubes: dismantled camp beds, clean clothes, letters, movies, dominoes, tiny Bibles, toothbrushes, skin creams. The smokers were first allowed only gum and nicotine patches, but doctors eventually relented and let 40 cigarettes a day go down.

The tubes also accommodated fiber optic cables and, by the end, each miner was getting a daily video consultation with a doctor. They also had jobs to do, including reinforcing walls and clearing debris from the rescue drills.

Meanwhile, Chris Matthews is an idiot:

If the trapped Chilean miners had subscribed to the tea party?s ?every-man-for-himself? philosophy, ?they would have been killing each other after about two days,? MSNBC host Chris Matthews said on his ?Hardball? show Wednesday night....

"You know these people, if they were every man for himself down in that mine, they wouldn't have gotten out.... They would have been killing each other after about two days.?

What that shows is that Matthews ? in stereotypical liberal fashion ? has forgotten the way private individuals cooperate and help each other. The government and only the government must be the source of all beneficence. If you don't want the government to solve all your problems, you must think you and everyone else can be 100% self-reliant.

Full post as published by Althouse on October 14, 2010 (boomark / email).