Home -> Law Blog Directory -> Academic Blogs -> Legal Theory Blog

Academic

: Legal Theory Blog

Cahn & Carbone on Family Paradigms, Class & Race, and Contraception

By Lawrence Solum

Naomi Cahn and June Carbone (George Washington University - Law School and University of Missouri at Kansas City School of Law) have posted Family Classes: Rethinking Contraceptive Choice on SSRN. Here is the abstract:

The political attention paid to moral values - in the context of the high profile fights over abortion, homosexuality, and abstinence education - has developed over the past quarter century in ideological terms as though race and class no longer existed. In fact, the changing understandings that attend family formation reflect a long term shift in the pathways to middle class life which has created a new technocratic elite - an elite that invests heavily in both men and women?s advanced degrees, and has remade family life to its advantage. The success of the new model, which we call the ?blue family paradigm,? and the sexual revolution at its core undermines what had once been consensus support for traditional values (which we will call ?the red family paradigm?), and for the structure of family life following from abstinence to courtship to marriage.

The result of the tensions between these family ideals has been a moral backlash. In this Article, we highlight the tensions between the two family models, focusing on contraception, and critique the class-based nature of the results. We argue that the politicization of family issues has produced its own ?vicious cycle? of moral concern, draconian changes that disproportionately affect the poorest and most vulnerable Americans, and a new round of moral panic justifying further punitive measures, as the initial restrictions (such as closing abortion clinics and slashing family planning funds) make matters worse. We conclude that the ?culture wars? are very much about class, and yet they are framed as a fight between two relatively privileged groups, in which class implications of the struggle disappear from sight. This Article argues that only by making these class implications visible - for low income, middle class, and wealthy individuals - can we design more effective interventions that can break the cycle.

Full post as published by Legal Theory Blog on May 04, 2010 (boomark / email).