Home -> Law Blog Directory -> Criminal Law Blogs -> Public Defender Dude

Criminal Law

: Public Defender Dude

Why are ex-Public Defenders so often bad judges

By PD Dude

I always get excited when someone from my office makes it to the bench (someone good, that is - if the person's a total political tool, then it's not so exciting). It means that finally, someone with our perspective is sitting on the bench. So, I have to ask myself all of the time this question: Why do ex-PDs make such uniformly bad judges. I mean, there are good judges who were PDs (or private lawyers, for that matter), but so many of the best judges I know were either District Attorneys or worked in the federal system. And I don't know why.I've heard the theories. One theory is that as a Public Defender, we've heard all of the bullshit that our clients put out and we no longer buy it. But, that would mean that only the most cynical Public Defenders make it to the bench (something that doesn't seem impossible, in light of the political process it takes to make it to the bench)...continue to full post

Full post as published by Public Defender Dude on December 15, 2007 (boomark / email).