Miscellaneous

Allstate asks U.S. Supreme Court to Dismantle Texas Statute

By E L Eversman

Although losing twice before in a Texas district court and before a 5th Circuit appellate court, Allstate Insurance and Ken Starr are hoping to convince the U.S. Supreme Court to take review of the Constitutionality of the Texas statute prohibiting insurance companies from owning collision repair shops.

Although Federal District Judge Ed Kinkeade wrote a compelling and well-reasoned decision identifying the inherent conflict of interest involved with insurers owning body shops, which was affirmed by the 5th Circuit, Allstate didn’t like the answer.  Making some of those moth-eaten arguments most of us haven’t seen since law school, Allstate will once again argue that the Texas law violates the Dormant Commerce Clause of The Constitution.

 Well, maybe Mr. Starr will fair better back in Washington, D.C. where his “starr” quality may have more appeal.

Allstate v. Abbott, U.S. Suprme Court Docket

Full post as published by AutoMuse on December 27, 2007 (boomark / email).