Litigation

Mandatory Arbitration in Employment Contracts

By Bruce Nye

Today's guest blawger is Michael Sachs, who practices employment law with our firm.

Today's Wall Street Journal discusses the increasing use of arbitration provisions in employment agreements.   The WSJ estimates as many as 20% of all businesses require employees to agree to submit employment disputes to binding arbitration and agree in advance to waive jury trial rights as a condition of employment. 

The article also discusses a Missouri case where the court applied an arbitration provision even where the employee failed to sign the agreement.  The court reasoned that by continuing to work, the employee had agreed to be governed by the arbitration provision.

Interestingly, a recent California Court of Appeals indicates the law here is exactly the opposite.  In Mitri v. Arnel Management Co. (2007) ___ C.A. 4th ___ , the employer brought a motion to compel arbitration based on an arbitration provision contained in its employee handbook.  The handbook stated that any dispute would be settled by arbitration and that as a condition of employment the employees were required to sign an arbitration provision.  The employer argued that such language, in conjunction with an acknowledgment of receipt and review of the handbook, created an arbitration provision.  The employees argued that there was no signed arbitration provision because this passage only alerted them that an arbitration agreement would be forthcoming and they would be required to sign that agreement, but that no such agreement was ever provided to or signed by them.  The California Court of Appeals held that the employees never agreed to arbitrate their claims and thus, the motion to compel arbitration was denied.

More discussion of the WSJ artice and a number of perspectives on arbitration appear here at Legal Blog Watch. 

                                                                                                                               --Michael Sachs

Full post as published by CalBizLit on December 18, 2007 (boomark / email).