International Law

'Free at Last:' Canadian Human Rights Commission Dismisses Complaints Against Mark Steyn, Macleans Magazine

This Globe and Mail report will come as no surprise:

The Canadian Human Rights Commission has dismissed a complaint against Maclean's magazine over a controversial article on the future of Islam, magazine officials said yesterday.

Meanwhile, a decision from the B.C. Human Rights Tribunal over the same issue isn't expected for several months.

The Canadian Islamic Congress launched the dual complaints over an article by Maclean's journalist Mark Steyn. The article, The Future Belongs to Islam, came under fire by Muslim critics who claimed it spreads Islamophobia.

Earlier this month, closing arguments were made before B.C.'s Human Rights Tribunal over the article, which appeared in Maclean's in October, 2006.

We've written much previously on this complaint, and have little to add to our original commentary of December 17, 2007:

For the record, then, let me state the obvious:

• These are merely complaints, and have not yet been adjudicated;
• Allegations such as these will not necessarily be substantiated through the complaint processes or at a hearing;
• Our press also has broad freedoms and protection in Canada - these will weigh heavily in the balance of any tribunal determination of these complaints.
• If the complaints are weak or frivolous, they are not likely to have any success at all. The complainants nonetheless have the right to be heard. That is how our judicial processes work and that too, is a freedom worth protecting.

For commentary on the fallout of this dismissal, see:

• Martyrdom denied, part deux - Dawg's Blog
• Canadian Human Rights Commission denies Steyn martyrdom -The Galloping Beaver
• Macleans Magazine Loses Its CHRC Complaint - Big City Lib
• Maclean's responds to recent decision from the Canadian Human Rights Commission - CNW Press Release

- Garry J. Wise, Toronto

Visit our Toronto Law Firm website: www.wiselaw.net

EMPLOYMENT LAW ? CIVIL LITIGATION ? WILLS AND ESTATES ? FAMILY LAW & DIVORCE

ORIGINALLY POSTED AT WISE LAW BLOG ? SUBSCRIBE TO WISE LAW BLOG

Full post as published by Wise Law Blog on June 27, 2008 (boomark / email).