Home -> Law Blog Directory -> Real Estate & Property Law Blogs -> a View from the property line
(866) 635-2689 for Personal Injury or (866) 635-9402 for Criminal Defense
Find a Local Lawyer
Divorce (866) 635-6190
Personal Injury (866) 635-2689
Criminal Defense (866) 635-9402
Real Estate & Property Law
: a View from the property line$15 Million for a Pool Drain? You bet!
By William G. Gammon
The Act promotes the safe use of pools, spas and hot tubs by imposing mandatory federal requirements for suction entrapment avoidance and by establishing a voluntary grant program for states with laws that meet certain minimum requirements as outlined in the Act. The Act is being administered by the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (the "CPSC"). Specifically, the Act requires that each public pool or spa utilize, among other things:
Safety Drain Covers. Each swimming pool or spa drain cover manufactured, distributed, or entered into commerce in the United States shall conform to the American National Standard ASME A112.19.8-2007 Suction Fittings for Use in Swimming Pools, Wading Pools, Spas, and Hot Tubs published by the American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME). Compliance with this Standard will be enforced by the CPSC as a consumer product safety rule.
Public Pool Drain Covers. Each public pool and spa (as defined), both new and existing, shall be equipped with drain covers conforming to the ASME A112.19.8-2007 Standard described above.
Public Pool Drain Systems. Each public pool and spa (pump) with a single main drain, other than an unlockable drain, shall be equipped with one or more additional devices or systems designed to prevent suction entrapment, that meet the requirements of any applicable ASME/ANSI Standard or applicable consumer product safety rule. In addition to a compliant drain cover, such additional devices or systems include a safety vacuum release system (the "SVRS"), or suction limiting vent system, or gravity drainage system, or automatic pump shut-off system, or drain disablement, or other system determined by the CPSC to be equally effective in preventing suction entrapment (see ASME A112.19.17).
Systems that Exceed the Federal Statute. All pools and spas configured to comply with ANSI/APSP - 7 American National Standard for Suction Entrapment Avoidance in Swimming Pools, Wading Pools, Spas, Hot Tubs, and Catch Basins, will automatically comply with each of the mandatory requirements listed above by virtue of its more stringent construction standard.
Which Pools are affected?
Now what is a "public" pool as defined by the act, and can the community association hope to dodge this legislation? No. "Public" pools as defined under the Act specifically include pools that are open exclusively to members of residential real estate developments such as community associations. So community association pools fall squarely within the target facilities governed by the Act. As such, all public pools, including those operated by community associations, must be equipped with a drain cover that is sold in the United States and meets certain Federal standards. The Act also requires, among other things, that all public pools with one main drain include at least one of a number of entrapment prevention safety systems which meets Federal standards.
So now to the punchline of the the article's headline: how can a pool drain cost the community association $15 million bucks? Simple. The Act authorizes a penalty of up to FIFTEEN MILLION DOLLARS PER OCCURRENCE or violation of the Act on a DAILY basis. It doesn't take a mathematician to calculate the catastrophic liability that non-compliance with the Act would levy on an unprepared or unsuspecting community association. Especially with budgeting sessions coming up for the next fiscal year, community associations need to be wary NOW of this legislation and its effects on pool maintenance and operation. If you are a director serving on your community association board, then please communicate with your pool vendor sooner rather than later and make sure that your pool meets the requirements of the Act. The old adage goes, "an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure." In this case, a few dollars spent now to comply with the Virginia Graeme Baker Act could save millions in fines (and LIVES) as the ultimate crux of the Act is to ensure that no more drownings result from the phenomenon known as suction entrapment.
A podcast of this article can be heard by clicking here or here, where yours truly served as producer and host of the CAI's "Community Spotlight" Radio Program, which can be heard each and every Friday on CNN 650 AM (click on the link "Click Here to Listen Live" in the right hand column of the page).
Full post as published by a View from the property line on August 25, 2008 (boomark / email).
Another Child Dies Due to Pool Drain System
One of the least known dangers for children is pool drains, which can have such powerful suction that they can hold a child under water or even pull organs from their bodies. Abigail Taylor, 6, died this week after struggling with the aftermath of such a nightmare: a wading pool drain at the [...
Pool Company President Criminally Charged in Death of Six-Year-Old Boy From Drain Accident
There is an interesting criminal case in Connecticut that falls on the borderline between criminal law and torts. The president of a residential pool company was criminally charged with manslaughter for the death of six-year-old Zachary Cohn, who drowned after having his arm caught in a pool drain...
Wrongful Death Lawsuit Filed in Death of Boy Who Drowned In Pool Drain Suction Accident
The parents of Zachary Cohn, a six-year-old boy who died last July after his arm got stuck in an underwater suction drain in the deep end of their swimming pool, have filed a wrongful death lawsuit against the town of Greenwich, Connecticut, Shoreline Pools, as well as several other defendants...
Pool Drain Lawsuit Filed Because of Drowning
Parents of a boy who drowned filed a lawsuit Monday, January 28 against the town of Greenwich, Shoreline Pools, and others. The 6 year-old drowned when his arm became caught in a powerful swimming pool drain...
ABC News Investigation Exposes Dangerous Pool Drains In Public Pools and Hotels Across the United States
A recent ABC News undercover investigation found that despite the known danger that pool drains can pose?especially to children?there are still public pools in the US that have yet to install safety drain covers and shut-off valves that are supposed to prevent kids from getting stuck or sucked into a drain?s powerful suction...
The Pop Tort: John Edwards and the Valerie Lakey case
For all the complaints about tort reformers supposedly relying upon urban legends to promote their cause, one more frequently sees trial lawyers promoting fictional versions of their victories...
Burst Drain Pipe
Town of Smithtown agrees to pay homeowners $260,000 property damage settlement.
Couple Awarded Nearly One Million Dollars in Lawsuit
Condo Lawsuit Gets $1 Million Award
$33 Million Awarded to Boy Injured by Drunken Driver
Drunk Driver To Pay $33 Million to Injured Friend
Reports of Child Deaths Prompt Recalls of Two Million Graco Strollers
Two Million Graco Strollers Recalled Four Strangulation Deaths Reported
Age Discrimination Suit Settled for $8.75 Million
Age Discrimination Class Action Settled for $8.75 Million
Verizon To Pay $52 Million To Settle
Verizon To Pay $52 Million To Settle "Pay as You Go" Data Charges FCC Investigation









