Legal Malpractice

Legal Malpractice in the Real and Cinematic Worlds

By (Andrew Lavoott Bluestone)

Burt Pugach and Linda Riss are a staple of the blogosphere and the Page Six world.  He was a lawyer who was convicted in 1959 for blinding Linda Riss by use of lye, went to jail ,came out of jail to marry her ,and then was disbarred.  He was determined to have practiced law through the use of a front man-lawyer in 2008.  But that is all part of the Page 6 portion of their lives.

Here, the two sold their life story to HBO for use in a film called "Crazy Love" and this is where the legal malpractice portion of their life comes in.  Was the deal fair, and did HBO owe them more money?

In Pugach v. HBO Pictures Inc., Slip Op. 2009 30489U we see that their legal malpractice action fails. Judge Kitzes of Supreme Court, Queens County writes: 

"This action arises out of an agreement between plaintiffs and defendant Shoot the Moon, dated May 11, 2004, whereby, in consideration of the payment of the sum of $ 2,000, plaintiffs granted Shoot the Moon an option to purchase all rights to their life stories...."  Plaintiff's argument that Linda Pucach could not read the contract because of her blindnes was disallowed on the basis that "if the party could not read it, "not to procure it to be read was equally negligent."

The legal malpractice action was dismissed as the attorney defendants represented Shoot the Moon and not plaintiffs, thus lacking privity.

Full post as published by New York Attorney Malpractice Blog on March 17, 2009 (boomark / email).