Home -> Law Blog Directory -> Ethics Blogs -> Legal Ethics Forum
(866) 635-2689 for Personal Injury or (866) 635-9402 for Criminal Defense
Find a Local Lawyer
Divorce (866) 635-6190
Personal Injury (866) 635-2689
Criminal Defense (866) 635-9402
Ethics
: Legal Ethics ForumABA releases Formal Opinion 10-457 regarding lawyer websites; collateral fight breaks out over ABA's assertion of copyright
First, the new opinion is a must read. (it will apparently be posted some time Wednesday morning at the ABA's Center for Professional Responsibility.) I've only skimmed it and although it doesn't break new ground, it does helpfully discuss issues of honesty, providing general information about law, how to handle website visitor inquiries, and disclaimers of duties to website visitors.
Second, Avvo has posted the actual opinion even thought the ABA has asserted copyright over it and asked that others not post it. Carolyn Elefant, at My Shingle, decided not to post it, out of respect for the ABA's request, but she says that she considered doing so as "civil disobedience." It's been a while since I've looked at this, but the copyright for ABA's formal opinions seems legit to me.
On the other hand, asserting copyright for model rules is a more complicated and difficult matter, because the very act of promulgating "model" enactments seems to presuppose that you want others to copy, use, adopt, and adapt your work product and because once any state enacts the rule, then the model and the law merge, and you can't assert a copyright over law. If I recall correctly, one of the leading ethics textbooks finessed this issue by including the model rules, but emphasizing that it was including Delaware's enactment of the rules. If I recall correctly -- and if I'm wrong you'd do me a favor of pointing it out in the comments -- there was a split in the cases about the enforceability of copyrights for model statutes.
Full post as published by Legal Ethics Forum on September 29, 2010 (boomark / email).
Copyright Lawsuits: Critical Issues Before Filing Copyright
Federa Rule 11(b) Considerations
Best Law Movies
Greatest Legal Movies selected by ABA Journal
Lawyer Jokes
Law Humor
Bextra Injury Risks
Bextra Increases Risk of Fatal Heart Attack
Bausch Lomb Renu Moistureloc Linked to Eye Infection Fusarium Keratiti
Contact Lens Solution Product Recall
Paxil Lawsuit
Paxil Claims, Lawsuits, and Injuries
Hurricane Ike
Gulf Coast Residents Fight for Compensation
Medtronic CD Horizon
allegedly recalled as defective device for being prone to failure, shearing and cable breaks.
Spike Lee and Showtime
Settlement reached in script copyright infringement lawsuit.
Joke Book
Judy Brown and publishers pay undisclosed settlement to comedians and talkshow celebrities for copyright infringement.
ASMP and Other Visual Artists File Class Action Lawsuit Against Google
Google Faces Class Action for Copyright Infringement
St. Louis Car Accident - St. Louis Auto Accident, St. Louis Car Accident Lawyer
St. Louis Car Accident alleging liability for personal injuries caused by car accidents in St. Louis, Missouri.

Ninth Circuit Upholds Under God in the Pledge of Allegiance,
Major Search Engines Sued for Copyright Violations
Immigration consequences collateral to Sixth Amendment: COM. V. PADILLA (SC 1/24/2008)
Like a Circuit Judge, But Not Exactly








