Home -> Law Blog Directory -> Religion & Law Blogs -> Religion Clause

Religion & Law

: Religion Clause

Fired Prison Chaplain States Valid 1st Amendment Claim

By Howard M. Friedman

In Holmgren v. State of Minnesota, (MN Ct. App., June 22, 2010, a Minnesota state appellate court held that a former prison chaplain's First Amendment free expression may have been violated when she was fired for speaking out against a new program being considered by the state which she believed would violate the Establishment Clause. Kristine Holmgren, employed as a non-denominational chaplain at the state's Shakopee facility, learned that the state-funded InnerChange Initiative Program was being considered for Shakopee. She believed the program's purpose was to convert inmates to Christianity using state dollars, and knew that a similar program was under court challenge in Iowa. (See prior posting.) She pressed the warden on the issue, including at a staff meeting, for which the warden fired her.

The court denied defendant's motion for summary judgment, concluding that the facts alleged by Holmgren were sufficient to establish a First Amendment violation. She at least raised a factual question as to whether she was speaking as a citizen rather than as part of her employment duties. Her criticisms involved a matter of public concern, and her right to speak about the issue outweighs the state's interest in an orderly work place. Defendant does not have qualified immunity because case law clearly establishes Holmgren's right not to be fired for raising potentially illegal conduct by government officials.

Full post as published by Religion Clause on June 24, 2010 (boomark / email).