Taxation & Estate Planning

The Agnes Wright Case and Loans vs. Gifts

By Joel A. Schoenmeyer

In re. Estate of Agnes H. Wright is an appellate case that deals with whether an individual's attorneys can be disqualified. The case is available here as a pdf. I'm less interested in that issue than in the issue that prompted the litigation in the first place. This is an undue influence case, pitting sibling vs. sibling. At issue is a trust amendment signed by Mrs. Wright. The trust amendment says that she loaned her son Peter $1.8 million to purchase a vacation home in Lake Geneva, Wisconsin. The amendment recites other information about the transaction, but the key is that the amendment characterizes the transaction as a loan. Peter, however, says that the transaction was a gift, and that the trust amendment was executed only because Peter's sister Linda exerted undue influence against their mother.

If I had any advice to take from the case, it would be this: resolve issues of loan vs. gift before death, by a writing signed by all parties. The problem in the above case is that the amendment is signed only by Mrs. Wright. If you want to loan money to a child, have the child agree to the terms of the loan BEFORE you hand over the money. Similarly, if you want to gift money to a child, think seriously about making equal gifts to all children OR having all children acknowledge that the gift IS a gift (not a loan).

Full post as published by Death and Taxes Blog on March 04, 2008 (boomark / email).