Home -> Law Blog Directory -> Legal Commentary Blogs -> TalkLeft

Legal Commentary

: TalkLeft

Latin American Commission: U.S. Drug War a Failure

By Jeralyn

A new report by the Latin American Commission on Drugs and Democracy blasts the war on drugs as a failure.

[The report] is the latest to question the U.S.'s emphasis on punitive measures to deal with illegal drug use and the criminal violence that accompanies it. A recent Brookings Institution study concluded that despite interdiction and eradication efforts, the world's governments haven't been able to significantly decrease the supply of drugs, while punitive methods haven't succeeded in lowering drug use.

Among the suggestions:

The panel recommends that governments consider measures including decriminalizing the use of marijuana.

[More...]

The panel was headed by former Brazilian President Fernando Henrique Cardo and also included former presidents Ernesto Zedillo of Mexico and César Gaviria of Colombia.

The report warned that the U.S.-style antidrug strategy was putting the region's fragile democratic institutions at risk and corrupting "judicial systems, governments, the political system and especially the police forces."

Is the U.S. likely to listen? Not likely:

"If the drug effort were failing there would be no violence," a senior U.S. official said Wednesday. There is violence "because these guys are flailing. We're taking these guys out. The worst thing you could do is stop now."

The report counters that focusing on the country of drug origin (as opposed to where they end up) has had little effect.

In Colombia, billions of dollars in U.S. aid have helped the military regain control from the hands of drug-financed communist guerrillas and lower crime, but the help hasn't dented the amount of drugs flowing from Colombia.

As the report notes, Europe has a better solution:

Mr. Gaviria said the U.S. approach to narcotics -- based on treating drug consumption as a crime -- had failed. Latin America, he said, should adapt a more European approach, based on treating drug addiction as a health problem.

Full post as published by TalkLeft on February 12, 2009 (boomark / email).