Legal Commentary

The never-ending City of Houston corruption probe

By Tom Kirkendall

It's been a couple of years since I last blogged on it, and it's been over two and a half years since the new defendants were first mentioned as potential targets in the probe, but the feds finally got around last week to indicting Andrew Schatte and Michael Surface, the principals in the Keystone Group who have made a living over the past decade or so managing big construction projects financed by the City of Houston and other municipalities. The press release on the indictment is here and a copy of the indictment is here. For unknown reasons, the U.S. District Clerk's office did not post the indictment publicly until yesterday.

The indictment alleges that Schatte and Surface bribed former City of Houston building services director Monique McGilbra to gain favor on a couple of big City of Housotn building projects for which they were competing. The feds allege that the bribes were both direct (not so big) and indirect (much larger), the latter of which were allegedly funneled through Garland Hardeman, McGilbra's former boyfriend who Schatte and Surface hired to work with them in obtaining the contracts. McGilbra, who copped a plea back in 2005, will be singing like a canary for the prosecution in this case.

Not enough is known about Schatte and Surface's defense strategy at this point to know what will be the most important issues in the case. However, one has to wonder why the U.S. Attorneys' office -- which has been investigating corruption in the City of Houston administration of former Mayor Lee P. Brown now for six years -- waited for over two and a half years after McGilbra had fingered Schatte and Surface to bring the charges against the two? Similarly, when did the feds notify Schatte and Surface that they were targets of a criminal probe? If it was some time ago (as it would appear), then why was Surface serving on the Harris County Sports & Convention Corp board for the past two years while being the target of a federal criminal probe?

The feds need to wrap this matter up.

Full post as published by Houston's Clear Thinkers on February 01, 2008 (boomark / email).