Intellectual Property Law

The Benefits of Early Registration of Copyrights Highlighted

By Tim Feathers

In a case that confirms the advisability of registering your copyright in software and websites, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has denied statutory damages in the context of a continuing infringement.  The copyright act does not allow statutory damages or attorney’s fees if the infringement “commenced” prior to the registration of the copyright (subject to a 3 month relation back exception for newly published works). 17 U.S.C. Sec. 412.

In Derek Andrews v. Poof Apparel, the defendant had copied the decorative tags that the plaintiff attached to its clothing items, and attached them to its own clothing line.  The tags gave rise to the copyright claim (the case also involved trademark infringement claims).  On the copyright claim, the District Court awarded the plaintiff $15,000 in statutory damages and  $296,090.50 in attorneys' fees.  The Court of Appeals stated that the Copyright Act leaves no room for discretion on this point: “in order to recover statutory damages, the copyrighted work must have been registered prior to commencement of the infringement, unless the registration is made within three months after first publication of the work.”  The court noted that other courts have construed Section 412 in a similar manner, finding that infringement commences for the purposes of § 412 when the first act in a series of acts constituting continuing infringement occurs. Accordingly, “the first act of infringement in a series of ongoing infringements of the same kind marks the commencement of one continuing infringement under § 412.”

The case highlights the importance of registering copyrights early.  One of the most frequent areas of copyright infringement we see involves software and content from websites (or entire websites themselves).  In these situations actual damages can be very difficult to prove, and the availability of attorneys fees and statutory damages greatly enhances your case, and ability to resolve these issues quickly and on favorable terms.

Full post as published by The TechKnowledgy Blog on June 18, 2008 (boomark / email).