New York

Earlier today, the New York Court of Appeals decided Berg v. Albany Ladder Co. -- a matter concerning Labor Law sec. 240(1).  In Berg, the plaintiff was hurt during the course of unloading steel trusses from a flatbed truck at a construction site.  The Appellate Division, Third Department Majority determined that the accident was not caused by the lack of a required safety device but, rather, by the improper movement of the trusses moved by a forklift.  The Court of Appeals affirmed, holding that the plaintiff failed to raise an issue of fact as to whether his fall was caused by the lack of safety device set out in sec. 240(1).  The Court seems to hint that this fall from approximately 10 feet up is not the type of height covered under sec. 240(1), citing Toeffer v. Long Island R. R.