Patent Law
: The Patent ProspectorFrivolous
By Gary Odom and Jordan Kuhn (all)
Triune
Star sued Disney, LG Electronics, and others, for infringing
6,122,521, which claims an infrared cell phone camera. Triune conceded that
defendants didn't have such a product, thus didn't literally infringe. Illinois
district court Judge Mihm blew off the possibility of doctrine of equivalents
owing to prosecution estoppel. He then pitched the case as frivolous, and
sanctioned Triune, granting defendants attorneys fees and costs.
The judge noted that a reasonable presuit investigation would have revealed the accused devices were non-infringing as a matter of law.
Rule 11 sanctions are rare. While patent defendants often feel they've been sued without good reason, there's typically not much they can do but eat the expense of slugging it out.
Full post as published by The Patent Prospector on November 30, 2008 (boomark / email).

Frivolous Lawsuits
Frivolous lawsuits? Ever hear someone complain that there is too much money being spent on frivolous lawsuits? Are frivolous lawsuits driving up the cost of insurance? What about health care? The answer is a resounding “no...
Those Darn Frivolous Malpractice Cases
Every medical malpractice case is frivolous, right? Some folks can't utter the words "malpractice lawsuit" in a sentence that doesn't include the word "frivolous...
Frivolous Tax Claims To Avoid
We may not avoid paying our fair share of taxes by making frivolous arguments such as those listed in this posting...
Marina Tylo Meets Barbara Streisand
Pop quiz: What happens when you file a frivolous lawsuit against a New York law blogger? Marina Tylo is about to learn...
?Frivolous Lawsuit? Commercials Distort The Truth
Image via Wikipedia While getting the kids ready for school in the morning, I often have the TV on some news program to check the weather, school closings and local happenings before work...
IRS Identifies Four New Frivolous Tax Positions
I previously blogged the IRS's new 70-page memorandum debunking dozens of tax protestor arguments...









