Home -> Law Blog Directory -> Litigation Blogs -> The Florida Jury Selection Blog
(866) 635-2689 for Personal Injury or (866) 635-9402 for Criminal Defense
Find a Local Lawyer
Divorce (866) 635-6190
Personal Injury (866) 635-2689
Criminal Defense (866) 635-9402
Litigation
: The Florida Jury Selection BlogProspective Juror Not “Under Prosecution.”
By Robert W. Kelley, Esq.
On the day the jury was sworn - after a week of voir dire - a prospective juror got a traffic ticket. The ticket was for the “crime” of knowingly driving on a suspended license, a second-degree misdemeanor. No one in the courtroom on that day asked her about it. She didn’t tell anyone about it. And she ended up serving on the jury that convicted Jason Tucker of premeditated first-degree murder. Tucker appealed his conviction on the grounds that Florida Statute 40.013(1) states: “No person who is under prosecution for any crime…shall be qualified to serve as a juror.” On Friday, the Fifth District Court of Appeal, while recognizing the undisputed nature of the “crime,” rejected his argument and affirmed the conviction. Tucker v. State 33 FLW D1617d (Fla 5th DCA, June 20, 2008).
The Appellate Court affirmed the conviction for two reasons: 1) this prospective juror was not “under prosecution” for this crime in this scenario (as used in the jury qualification statute) because the state attorney had not exercised his discretion to pursue the charges against her through formal judicial proceedings (i.e. merely getting the ticket was not enough), and 2) even if this juror was “under prosecution” during jury service, a new trial was not warranted because there was no showing of prejudice by Tucker.
Full post as published by The Florida Jury Selection Blog on June 23, 2008 (boomark / email).
What I Was Just Sampling the Evidence
Pop Quiz: You’re a prospective juror for a marijuana possession case. What’s the best way to avoid jury duty? A prospective juror in a marijuana possession trial was hauled off to jail Tuesday after police said they caught her smoking…
Boston Juror, Judge Go Toe-to-Toe Over Nullification Issue
Back in March, we blogged a Time article written by the creators of “The Wire.” The piece described the country’s “unwinnable drug war” as having turned from “a battle against dangerous substances” into “a venal war on our underclass...
EDNY Judge Denies Motion for New Trial Premised on Allegedly False Statements by Juror During Voir Dire
A prospective juror who says he?s a political science professor, albeit also a lawyer who has not practiced for the last six years, sounds like a good defense gamble. After all, liberal professors outnumber conservatives in the social sciences by...
“Fraud on the PTO”
Here’s a special guest post on the TTABlog that lays out the state of the law regarding the increasingly confusing, and sometimes distressing, issue for trademark lawyers of what constitutes “fraud” in the prosecution and maintenance of federal trademark applications and registrations...
"Prospective juror in pot trial caught smoking marijuana; Woman charged with drug possession on break from trial"
"Prospective juror in pot trial caught smoking marijuana; Woman charged with drug possession on break from trial": This article appears today in The Houston Chronicle.
The American Jury System: A Whole Lot Of Gaming Going On
Before we return to the meltdown of our financial system, let’s check in on the meltdown of our jury system. “Jury duty is like the speed limit,” writes Nathan Koppel in a WSJ article entitled, ‘Excuse Me, Your Honor, The Dog Ate My Civic Duty...










