Home -> Law Blog Directory -> Labor & Employment Law Blogs -> New York Public Personnel Law

Labor & Employment Law

: New York Public Personnel Law

Payment for vacation credits upon resignation

Payment for vacation credits upon resignation
Karp v North Country Community College, 258 AD2d 775

After 15 years of service, Robert Karp resigned from his position with the North Country Community College in 1997. When the college refused to pay him for accrued vacation credits he claimed he accrued between 1982 and 1985, he sued.

Although Karp admitted that the college lacked express authority to pay him for his unused vacation time, he nevertheless claimed that he was entitled to such payments because the college had paid other employees for unused vacation time in the past. Karp argued that this meant that the college was obligated to pay him for such credits as well.

Karp claimed that in 1986 two employees received compensation for their unused vacation time when they resigned. He also referred to a 1986 memorandum written by respondent?s then-Dean of Administration recognizing that the school?s policy respecting unused vacation time needed clarification and that, in the interim, respondent would honor its past practice for vacation time accrued up until August 31, 1985.

Supreme Court said that if not expressly authorized by statute, local law, resolution or pursuant to a contract term, a public employee may not be paid for unused vacation time, citing General Municipal Law Section 92. The court noted that payments made without such authority are deemed public gifts, prohibited by Article VIII, Section 1 of the New York State Constitution.

The Appellate Division agreed, commenting that ?the mere fact that [the college] despite lacking authority to do so, may have on prior occasions compensated employees for unused vacation time does not validate [Karp?s] claim. Express authorization being required, prior conduct cannot satisfy the express statutory authorization needed to form a basis for recovery against a public body.?

Also noted was the fact that in 1986 the college advised Karp that he should develop a plan to use any remaining vacation time during that academic year.
NYPPL

Full post as published by New York Public Personnel Law on November 16, 2010 (boomark / email).