Estate Planning

Stop the Presses?

By Hull & Hull LLP

The meaning of life is that it stops.  --- Franz Kafka

If you are familiar with Kafka and his short literary works, you will know that he was a tortured literary genius who was unsure of his own talent to the point of torment.  In 1924, dying of tuberculosis, Kafka wrote to his friend of 20 years and fellow novelist, Max Brod.  Kafka had made a list of his three novels and a number of stories and gave strict instructions to Brod to destroy all his manuscripts 'unread and in their entirety' and to ensure that already published works would never be re-printed.  These instructions were not contained with a formal last will and testament, rather they were a penciled note found in a drawer after his death.

Kafka's lover, Dora Diamont, partially executed his wishes by stashing away letters and notebooks until they were seized by the Gestapo in 1933. Sidebar: These papers are the subject of an ongoing international search.  Brod, however, ignored his friend's wishes and instead oversaw the publication of the works in his possession.  Brod's defence was that if Kafka had really wanted the works destroyed, he would have appointed another, more ruthless executor. Kafka, had, according to Brod, trusted Brod to not burn his writings.

Interesting question, perhaps not in the legal sense, but in a moral and ethical sense: Is it possible that Kafka undermined his own intentions by the very nature of the relationship he had with his executor?

Full post as published by Toronto Estate Law Blog on March 05, 2008 (boomark / email).