Home -> Law Blog Directory -> Consumer Law Blogs -> CL&P Blog
(866) 635-2689 for Personal Injury or (866) 635-9402 for Criminal Defense
Find a Local Lawyer
Divorce (866) 635-6190
Personal Injury (866) 635-2689
Criminal Defense (866) 635-9402
Consumer Law
: CL&P BlogConsumer advocate fights off trademark arbitration claim
By Greg Beck
by Greg Beck
Robert Arkow runs a website at the domain names metrolinkrider.com and metrolinksucks.com (no
longer active) where riders and employees of Metrolink, the Southern California commuter rail system, share their gripes about services and fares. Metrolink filed a complaint under the Uniform Domain Name Dispute Resolution Policy (UDRP), an agreement imposed by ISPs that subjects domain-name owners to mandatory arbitration for challenges to their ownership of domain names. Metrolink claimed that the domain names were confusingly similar to its own and were registered in bad faith. Metrolink was particularly peeved about postings on the site "with such statements as 'Stupid Metrolink Tricks---Seen something really dumb on Metrolink?' and 'Are the Engineers that stupid?'"
The arbitration panel denied the complaint, siding with the pro se domain name owner. Noting a split in past decisions on the issue, the panel held that noncommercial use of a trademark in a domain name for purposes of comment or criticism did not violate the UDRP. It wrote: "[S]omething more than criticism is required to establish illegitimacy and bad-faith for purposes of the [UDRP]."
Use of trademark law to squelch criticism is an ongoing problem, and is of particular concern when claims are brought in international tribunals that aren't bound by the First Amendment. Here, it looks like the panel reached the right result. Public Citizen successfully defended another web critic against a similar UDRP claim by a homebuilder earlier this year.
The Citizen Media Law Project drew my attention to this case, and has lots more background on the UDRP.
Full post as published by CL&P Blog on May 27, 2008 (boomark / email).
Domain Name Disputes: Arbitration versus Litigation
The conclusion? Arbitration! Here is an excerpt from Sarah Bird?s SEOMoz.org blog, Trademark Law and Domain Names: ACPA or UDRP?: "If you believe someone is infringing your trademark in bad faith, consider bringing an UDRP Arbitration...
Anti-Arbitration Bills Imperil the Universal Benefits of Consumer Arbitration
That is the title of an article by Kirk Knutson that appears in the latest issue of Metropolitan Corporate Counsel, a publication for legal professionals. The article discusses several anti-arbitration bills that have been introduced in Congress, their potential effects on consumer arbitration, and the underlying myths steering them...
Arbitration Agreements Increasing
Binding arbitration agreements are increasing between physicians, nursing homes and healthcare institutions. Some states have started taking legislative action to limit the agreements...
Arbitration: "Be Careful What You Wish For"
Not long ago arbitration was one of the darlings of the anti-court, anti-lawyer crowd. Courts and lawyers cheated poor people and arbitration was a solution. Now mandatory arbitration clauses are common in consumer industries and there is a bill pending...
Ware on Securities Arbitration
What Makes Securities Arbitration Different from Other Consumer and Employment Arbitration?, by STEPHEN J. WARE, University of Kansas - School of Law, was recently posted on SSRN. Here is the abstract: This short piece emphasizes what makes consumer and employment...
Video: Empowered Consumer Tells Her Arbitration Story
Sharon Kruse, a 63 year old consumer from Michigan, tells her empowering story about how she used arbitration to resolve her small dispute with a big company. In doing so she felt "powerful and proud"...
Truth In Lending Act
Consumer Loans and Consumer Credit Protection Act
Ladder Accident Injury Claims
Were you or a loved one injured in a ladder accident?
Adidas Imitators
Payless Shoesource to pay $304.6 million settlement in trademark lawsuit.
West Virginia Child Advocate Office Faces Class Action over Child Support
West Virginia Child Advocate Office Faces Class Action over Child Support
AIG Settles Injury Claim
for $18 Million
Failure-to-accommodate claim yields $1.82M award
$1.82 Million Awarded in Employment Lawsuit
Advocate
$3.5 Million Settlement Approved for Uninsured Patients
Recovery Claim
Florida Insurance Guarantee Association agrees to pay $14 million settlement to Home Solutions of America for construction services.
#1 Online Legal Resource
On 08-25 at 15:46PM
Acute perpendicular parking #NYPD #NYFD
On 08-18 at 22:18PM
Parallel parking gone bad. Too much gas UES NYC
On 08-18 at 21:41PM
UES NYC
On 08-18 at 21:25PM
Twitter suspends journalist critical of broadcast partner's coverage on dubious grounds @guyadams #nbcfail #twitterfail
On 07-30 at 17:57PM
Model example of 1st Amendment suppression by the People of New York City's Michael Bloomberg #OWS #NYPD
On 07-12 at 21:07PM
AG Holder lackadaisical on Operation in our Sites domain name seizures & RIAA lobbied free speech suppression @dajaz1
On 06-08 at 22:44PM
Why is the Catholic Church going to court over Obama contraception policy? @NewYorker commentary
On 05-31 at 10:08AM
Monks sue Louisiana for right to sell caskets made from forrest destroyed by Katrina
On 05-31 at 07:47AM
Are the abortion ultrasound laws headed for the Supreme Court?
On 05-15 at 21:52PM
 |
|
Contact Us | About Us | Celebrity Law Blog |
Our Partners | Disclaimer
| Law Blog Directory
| Law Jobs
| Law Tweets
| Oil Spill Video
All original material © 1999-2011 by USLaw.com. All other material, including Blog Directory feed content, are © by their respective copyright holders. |