Academic

Dorf & McElroy on Retired Justices Citizen by Designation

By Lawrence Solum

Michael C. Dorf and Lisa McElroy (Cornell Law School and Drexel University - Earle Mack School of Law) have posted Coming Off the Bench: Legal and Policy Implications of Proposals to Allow Retired Justices to Sit by Designation on the Supreme Court on SSRN. Here is the abstract:

Senator Patrick Leahy recently introduced a bill that would override a New-Deal-era federal statute forbidding retired justices from serving by designation on the Supreme Court of the United States. The Leahy bill would authorize the Court to recall willing retired justices to substitute for recused justices. This Article uses the Leahy bill as a springboard for considering a number of important constitutional and policy questions, including: whether the possibility of 4-4 splits justifies substitution of a retired justice for an active one; whether permitting retired justices to substitute for recused justices would violate Article III?s requirement that there be ?one Supreme Court;? and whether the ethical limitations on extra-judicial activities should be the same for active and retired judges and justices. In addition to relying on published material, the authors draw on information gleaned from their interview with retired Justice John Paul Stevens, who was the original source of the Leahy proposal.

Full post as published by Legal Theory Blog on February 23, 2011 (boomark / email).