Estate Planning

Dependant's Relief and Jointly Owned Insurance Policies

By Hull & Hull LLP

The Court of Appeal recently rendered its decision in Madore-Ogilvie and Ogilvie v. Ogilvie Estate, 2008 ONCA 39.  One of the issues was whether the proceeds from a jointly owned life insurance policy could be included in the deceased’s estate for the purposes of satisfying a dependant’s relief claim. 

One of our previous blogs reviews the facts of the case and the appellate decision of the Divisional Court, which I will not repeat except to say that the Divisional Court reversed the application judge’s finding that the policy could be included as part of the estate, and decided that the contractual rights of the spouse to the joint policy trumped the needs of the deceased’s dependants.

Two of the minor children appealed the Divisional Court’s decision and asked that the application judge's decision be restored.  The deceased’s spouse cross-appealed. 

The Court of Appeal dismissed both the appeal and the cross-appeal, finding as follows:

-          the policy was not caught within the ambit of section 72(1)(f) of the Succession Law Reform Act;

-          the policy was not an arrangement that was made to jeopardize the maintenance of the deceased’s dependants; and

-          section 199 of the Insurance Act did not apply to the policy.

Have a good day,

Natalia

Full post as published by Toronto Estate Law Blog on March 26, 2008 (boomark / email).