Bankruptcy

The Student Debt Debate: Who?s to Blame?

By Chris Kramer

Student loans provide people chances for their education, dreams and future career opportunities. But what happens when it?s time face the hefty debt waiting after graduation?

Who is to blame if the recent grad gets overwhelmed with debt and can't afford to pay their loans back?

A recent New York Times article profiled one indebted grad and tried to address all the parties involved.

For students like Courtney Munna, blame is no longer her concern. Now she regrets taking out $100,000 in student loans to attend N.Y.U. and wishes she made better financial decisions regarding the loans.

Since graduation in 2005, Munna has deferred her loans as a short term solution to scrape by and pay the rest of her bills.

But the question still remains, who?s to blame for students like Munna getting in over their heads.

The article said that both the students and their families have personal responsibilities to know their finances and take out loans they can afford to pay back.

The article also placed some responsibility on the universities since they have access to student?s finances after they fill out the financial aid forms, and are in a familiar situation helping students find aid. Students, on the other hand, are often overly trusting of universities to look out for their best interest.

The Times suggests that these schools should advise prospective students they cannot afford their school, an idea that Vice President of Enrollment at N.Y.U. Randall Deike said ?would be completely inappropriate.? Besides discrimination issues, it?s not the schools decision to make whether or not a student can afford their school.

Their business is to enlist students, not turn them away. Deike agreed that prospective students should not take on too much debt, but he said that?s their decision.

There are other reasons universities do not want to tell students to search for a cheaper education. They said it might reflect poorly on their school and suggest that their education might not provide opportunities after graduation.

The lenders themselves have continued to take the blame for loaning too much money with too lax of standards. In Munna?s case she was approved for $40,000 in loans by Citibank, even after she was already deep in debt.

As of now, Munna makes $22 an hour and barely makes the bills. She knows she?s responsible for taking out to much money in loans. But said she doesn?t ?want to spend the rest of her life slaving away to pay for an education?[she] would happily give back.?

Student loans typically take decades to repay, even if the student is fortunate to find a well-paying job after graduating. Many students see a series of forbearance and deferrals while they wait to land the right job, as interest and fees pile onto their original loans.

And there is typically no way to eliminate student loans other than to pay them in full. Currently, student loans are one of the rare types of debt that cannot be discharged in bankruptcy.

Full post as published by The Bankruptcy Blog on June 10, 2010 (boomark / email).