Home -> Law Blog Directory -> Legal Niches Blogs -> Agricultural Law

Legal Niches

: Agricultural Law

Beyond food and evil (revisited)

By Jim Chen at al.

Herewith an extension of my original post regarding my paper, Beyond Food and Evil, as reprinted from The Cardinal Lawyer:

I am pleased to present this RealPlayer video  of my presentation at the Duke Law Journal's 37th Annual Administrative Law Conference. This year's conference, staged on February 2, 2007, focused on the administrative state's regulation of food.

I also invite you to download and read the finished product: Jim Chen, Beyond Food and Evil, 56 Duke L.J. 1581 (2007):

The mass marketing of foods derived from organisms modified through recombinant DNA technology has put extreme pressure on the interpretation and implementation of the United States' basic food safety law, the venerable Food, Drug & Cosmetic Act. In its classic form, the FD&CA reflects its Progressive and New Deal roots. It vests enormous trust in a specialized agency, the Food and Drug Administration, which is presumed to have nonpareil expertise over food safety. The political reality of GM foods, however, has placed the FD&CA and its implementation by the FDA in severe tension with the Organic Foods Production Act and with commercial speech doctrine.

Fear about food is one of the most deeply seated forms of behavioral protection against the natural world. It is precisely here, where food comes into contact with notions of good and evil, that the classic regulatory state must take its stand. The FDA's regulation of foods using rDNA technology upholds the best of the Progressive regulatory tradition and deserves to survive the challenge posed by the OFPA, the revived commercial speech doctrine, and contemporary consumer distrust of governmentally supervised review of science and safety.

Beyond Food and Evil has had an active academic life since February. I presented this paper at the University of Arkansas on November 1, 2007, as part of my official visit at Arkansas. In addition, Professor Donna Byrne has discussed Beyond Food and Evil on her Food Law Prof Blog.

Full post as published by Agricultural Law on November 15, 2007 (boomark / email).