Legal Commentary

Lone Survivor

By Tom Kirkendall

I recently finished reading Lone Survivor: The Eyewitness Account of Operation Redwing and the Lost Heroes of SEAL Team 10 (Little, Brown and Company 2009), Marcus Luttrell?s engrossing story of his experience in surviving a vicious battle against the Taliban in Afghanistan. I recommend the book highly to anyone who is interested in United States foreign policy.

Lone Survivor is not a great book. A substantial part of it - particularly the parts of Luttrell?s Navy SEAL training - are repetitive and unnecessary. Likewise, Luttrell?s political views are somewhat simplistic and do not add much to the story.

But Luttrell?s story is spot on in portraying the troubling problem that the U.S. Armed Forces face in fighting wars under rules of engagement that constrain doing what is necessary to accomplish the purpose of the war. During their mission, Luttrell and his squad mates had to make a key decision under the rules of engagement ? and it was not even a clearly wrong one ? that ultimately resulted in a disaster for the squad.

Luttrell?s story is also insightful from a cultural standpoint. After fending off over a hundred Taliban attackers in battle, Luttrell was ultimately saved by members of an Afghan community who decided to resist the Taliban. The cultural dynamics at play are as confusing as they are fascinating.

Should the United States be sending true American heroes such as Luttrell and his comrades into such a complicated cultural conflict under rules that hinder them from accomplishing the mission?

It is a question that should be much more difficult for our government?s leaders than it appears to be.

Full post as published by Houston's Clear Thinkers on January 31, 2010 (boomark / email).