Home -> Law Blog Directory -> Legal Commentary Blogs -> Althouse

Legal Commentary

: Althouse

Judith Warner reflects on the occasion of ending her NYT family life column.

Now, this is freaky. Just 2 days ago I ripped Judith Warner:

I don't ? I can't ?use the raw material of my home life for blog posts ... and I've been noticing how much these various female columnists do.... They just go right ahead and talk about whatever is right there in their home and make casual generalizations about what people are like these days.

Like Judith Warner, writing in the NYT this week about her daughter... The daughter has "endless girl dramas," and the mother has adopted a "respectful distance" strategy of parenting. But part of that "respectful distance" is blabbing about the dramas in the New York Times. Well, that is a kind of distance....

This is the style of these relationship columns for women these days. Write openly about your own family. Of course, it's fundamental that you have a lovely, happy family ? and that they won't get any less happy and lovely if you make them your material.

And now, today, here's Judith Warner, signing off, saying:

I?m glad now to have the chance to get back to being more fully present in the life I?ve been mining for material these many years.

Now, I'm not suggesting I had anything to do with ending Judith Warner's column. Even if I think my writing has some effect, I don't think it could work that quickly. But I do think I perceived a problem that Warner herself really did feel. Or maybe she's just looking for the bright side.

Full post as published by Althouse on December 18, 2009 (boomark / email).