Home -> Law Blog Directory -> Religion & Law Blogs -> Religion Clause

Religion & Law

: Religion Clause

Collateral Defendants Settle In Suit Claiming Religion In Class of Ohio Science Teacher

By Howard M. Friedman

In June 2008, a Mt. Vernon, Ohio family filed a federal civil rights suit against controversial Middle School science teacher John Freshwater, claiming that he taught religion in his classroom. Also named as defendants in the lawsuit were he school board, Superintendent Steve Short and middle school principal William White. The suit alleged they allowed Freshwater to continue his unconstitutional activities after being notified of his violations of school policy. (See prior posting.) According to the Mt. Vernon News, on Wednesday the school board met and approved a settlement covering all defendants except teacher John Freshwater.

Under the settlement, negotiated by the Board's insurance carrier, the other defendants agreed to pay $115,500 for plaintiffs' legal fees, and damages of $5,500 to one plaintiff, along with nominal damages of $1 each to two others. The settlement also bars staff from discussing the case with students. It calls for training in church-state issues for board members, administrators and teachers. This has already been done. Finally the school board is to make a public statement at the conclusion of the pending administrative hearing on whether Freshwater should be fired. (See prior posting.) The settlement must be approved and approved by the Probate Court of Knox County before a motion to dismiss is filed in federal court. the National Center for Science Education also has a report on developments in the case.

Full post as published by Religion Clause on August 28, 2009 (boomark / email).