Legal Commentary

The Gates-gate Dispatches

By Big Tent Democrat

The tapes from Gates-gate are out (Transcripts here.) The 911 call makes Lucia Whalen, the person who called in, look good - she says she does not know what is going on. Does not mention "black men." In fact she said that they looked "kind of hispanic." The 911 dispatcher seems brusque.

The dispatch is pretty fuzzy too. Then Crowley seems to answer. Then a call in that "the gentleman says he resides here but it uncooperative." Then a call in to Harvard police. Then Gates is mentioned by name. Clearly he gave his name and identification to Crowley.

Then a call for "the wagon" to the location. This certainly is not helpful to Crowley's account. Update - for those who argue that Crowley's assertion in his police report that he spoke to Whalen at the scene may explain his reference to "two black men with backpacks" is belied by the fact that Whalen's attorney said "[Whalen n]ever once in any of her statements, conversations, and so forth did she ever use the word black. . . . But more importantly, when Sergeant Crowley got there, she didn’t have a conversation with him at all."

Speaking for me only

Comments closed.

Full post as published by TalkLeft on July 28, 2009 (boomark / email).