Home -> Law Blog Directory -> Legal Commentary Blogs -> Althouse

Legal Commentary

: Althouse

"Does the United States really want to be a country that sends horses to slaughter, here or abroad?"

"Throughout history, horses have paid an excruciating price as we built our civilizations on their backs, forced them into our bloody wars and bestowed on them the agonizing fate of being the predominant mode of transportation. Humanity owes the horse, and a 21st-century horse-loving nation ought to ensure a life, and death, of dignity for these animals."

A letter to the editor. Here's the underlying news story about slaughtering horses:

An estimated 100,000 horses a year are shipped to Canada and Mexico for slaughter, prompting Congress to consider a bill that would ban the sale and transport of horses for human consumption outside the country. But Arkansas, Georgia and eight other states are against such a ban, saying owners need affordable options for unwanted horses.

Last week in Montana, the Legislature approved a bill allowing the construction of horse-slaughter facilities....

?Bottom line is you have to separate the animal from the pet,? said State Representative Edward B. Butcher, a Republican who wrote the Montana bill.

Butcher....

?No one has to send a horse to a processing plant,? he added. ?It?s just an option for horses that are unusable. And it?s much more humane than leaving them there to starve to death.?

There are a lot of issues here ? including federalism, one of my favorite issues: Is this a matter that ought to be dealt with at the state or the national level?

But what I'm most interested in myself is the letter-writer's argument. Should we take a moral position on the individual animal in light of the historical contribution of the species? Is it okay to slaughter cattle ? because they were always only about food ? but not okay to slaughter horses ? because of all the work they've done for us? Some horses have gone to battle, so all horses should be honored? Is this a good moral argument?

Full post as published by Althouse on April 13, 2009 (boomark / email).