South Carolina Opens Door to Negligent Hiring Claim
By John A. Day
The South Carolina Supreme Court has ruled that a defendant employer may not avoid a claim for negligent hiring, training, supervision, or entrustment by simply agreeing that it is vicariously liable for the actions of its employee.
In James v. Kelly Trucking Company, the Court said that just because a company is vicariously liable for acts of an employee does not mean that it cannot be liable for its own negligence. As the Court explained, "[a] plaintiff may, in a single lawsuit, assert many causes of action against a defendant. The considerations limiting a plaintiff’s available causes of action in the typical case are that the plaintiff must be able to demonstrate a prime facie case for each cause of action and that a plaintiff may ultimately recover only once for an injury."
The opinion also gives a nice summary of the common law of negligent hiring, training, supervision, or entrustment: "in circumstances where an employer knew or should have known that its employment of a specific person created an undue risk of harm to the public, a plaintiff may claim that the employer was itself negligent in hiring, supervising, or training the employee, or that the employer acted negligently in entrusting its employee with a tool that created an unreasonable risk of harm to the public. See Restatement (Second) of Torts § 317 (1965) (Cited with approval in Degenhart v. Knights of Columbus, 309 S.C. 114, 116, 420 S.E.2d 495, 496 (1992))."
The dissent argued that "a plaintiff may proceed on a negligent hiring claim when the employer admits vicarious liability only if there is evidence of gross negligence in hiring that would support an award of punitive damages."
TORTS: South Carolina Opens Door to Negligent Hiring Claim John Day at Day on Torts Blog posts on a South Carolina decision - South Carolina Opens Door to Negligent Hiring Claim. Does anyone know if that door has been opened or closed here in Kentucky? If so, post the case in comments (and I will move it up here!).
South Carolina goes back in closet Gawker: The South Carolina state tourism agency has canceled an overseas ad campaign targeting the gays, which used the slogan "South Carolina is so gay." The state will save itself five thousand bucks by not paying for the previously approved posters, which, as we mentioned, read "South Carolina is so gay...
South Carolina Blogs If you?re interested in technology, check out the South Carolina Trial Law Blog: Using Technology to be a Better Trial Lawyer . For weekly updates on current topics in appellate law, try South Carolina Appellate Law Blog: Following the Opinions of the South Carolina Appellate Courts, the Fourth Circuit, and the United States Supreme Court...
Next Stop Graniteville A lawyer who is admitted in Louisiana and South Carolina had practiced only in Louisiana but opened a South Carolina law office in order to solicit legal business in the wake of a train derailment in Graniteville South Carolina...