Home -> Law Blog Directory -> Litigation Blogs -> The Florida Jury Selection Blog

OR PHONE (866) 635-1838 for Bankruptcy Help, (866) 635-6190 for Divorce,
(866) 635-2689 for Personal Injury or (866) 635-9402 for Criminal Defense

Find a Local Lawyer

Bankruptcy (866) 635-1838
Divorce (866) 635-6190
Personal Injury (866) 635-2689
Criminal Defense (866) 635-9402

Litigation

: The Florida Jury Selection Blog

Can A Potential Juror Be Asked To “Promise” A Verdict?

By Robert W. Kelley, Esq.

ADVERTISEMENTS

A common technique in voir dire, especially by defense attorneys, is to ask each prospective juror during jury selection whether the juror will “promise” to return a certain kind of verdict (e.g. guilty or not guilty) if it is supported by the evidence. Many trial judges for a variety of reasons will not permit that type of question to be answered. Last month, in the case of Benayer v. State, the Fourth District Court of Appeal implicitly approved that specific voir dire question in a brief opinion dealing with the issue of a jury’s pardon power. In Benayer, the trial judge himself had asked the prospective jurors whether they would “promise” to find the defendant guilty if they were convinced of his guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. The Defendant objected to the question. The Fourth District reviewed the record and held the question was not error. The Defendant’s conviction was affirmed. This case, while not directly on point, certainly belongs in the trial notebook of any trial lawyer who plans to ask a prospective jury panel for any sort of “promise” during voir dire.

Full post as published by The Florida Jury Selection Blog on August 19, 2010 (boomark / email).

Related Law Blog Posts

Search Blog Directory:

Twit: Juror Jonathan Throws Verdict Into Doubt With Improper Tweets
Russell Wright and his company, Stoam Holdings has a novel ground to challenge the $12.6 million verdict against them. They have given the court proof that a juror posted messages on Twitter...

U.S. Supreme Court Upholds Governments Juror Strike Based on Her Demeanor and Body Language No Batson Violation
On Feb. 22, 2010, the U.S. Supreme Court reversed a 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals decision regarding the “demeanor-based” rejection of a potential juror in a death penalty case...

Criminal Trials: "Juror: Stinson verdict was a "no brainer" - WHAS11
WHAS news story on unidentified juror regarding Stinson trial: Juror: Stinson verdict was a "no brainer" 11:57 PM EDT on Monday, September 21, 2009 WHAS11 Coverage Tell Us: Do you agree with the verdict in the Stinson trial? Raw: Entire closing argument from Stinson defense Raw: Entire closing argument from Stinson prosecution Video: The verdict is announced (WHAS11) - For the first time since they acquitted former coach Jason Stinson, a juror on that case is talking about the decision to clear him...

CRIMINAL - Disqualified juror sitting: Commonwealth v. Brewer (COA 10/30/2009)
Commonwealth v. Brewer 2008-CA-001503 10/30/09 2009 WL 3486704 Opinion by Judge Acree; Judges Taylor and Thompson concurred. The Court reversed a trial court order declaring a jury verdict void ab initio and granting appellee a new trial and ordered the trial court to reinstate the verdict and enter a judgment of conviction...

Are juror tweets grounds for a new trial
When judges tells jurors not to discuss a case with anyone, they also mean via social networks such as Twitter. A $12.5 verdict is being challenged in Arkansas over a juror sending “tweets” - the 140-character posts on the Twitter micro-blogging network...

In Stevens Trial, A Request to Oust Juror for Violent Outbursts
Given how Sen. Ted Stevens’s trial has gone so far, we didn’t expect that the jury would simply return a verdict and everyone would leave quietly. This just in: This afternoon, reports the WSJ, U...

Search Blog Directory:

Lawsuits and Settlements

$1.5 Million Asbestos Mesothelioma Verdict Against Fisher Controls International
$1.5 Million Asbestos Mesothelioma Verdict

$1.5 Million Verdict for Injured Worker
$1.5 Million Verdict for Injured Worker

$11,000,000 Verdict Awarded in Nursing Home Wrongful Death Suit
$11,000,000 Verdict Awarded in Nursing Home Wrongful Death Suit

$31 Million Verdict
Against Camden New Jersey

Morgan Drexen Faces Potential Federal Class Action
Morgan Drexan FAces Potential Class Action

Kia Motors America, Inc.
Kia Class Action Ends in $6 Million Verdict for Plaintiffs in NJ

Related Searches