Home -> Law Blog Directory -> Appellate Law Blogs -> North Carolina Appellate Blog

OR PHONE (866) 635-1838 for Bankruptcy Help, (866) 635-6190 for Divorce,
(866) 635-2689 for Personal Injury or (866) 635-9402 for Criminal Defense

Find a Local Lawyer

Bankruptcy (866) 635-1838
Divorce (866) 635-6190
Personal Injury (866) 635-2689
Criminal Defense (866) 635-9402

Appellate Law

: North Carolina Appellate Blog

COA: Deed Of Trust Canceled Without Authorization Enjoys Priority Over Later Deed Of Trust, Despite Later Lender's Reliance On Cancellation

By Sean E. Andrussier

ADVERTISEMENTS

Today in Household Realty Corp. v. Lambeth the Court of Appeals (COA) addressed a priority issue concerning deeds of trust. A deed of trust held by the first lender was fraudulently canceled by the unauthorized act of a third party. In reliance on that cancelation, a second lender furnished a loan and obtained a deed of trust. When the unauthorized cancellation came to light, a priority dispute arose: which deed of trust should have priority to be a superior lien on the property?

The trial court held that the first deed of trust, the one canceled without authorization, should have priority. The trial court ordered that it be reinstated as a lien on the property effective from its original recordation date. The second lender appealed, arguing that, because it relied on the recorded cancellation, it should have a superior lien. The COA agreed with the trial court, holding that the first deed of trust was entitled to priority over the second lender's deed of trust, even though the second lender made its loan in reliance on the presumed validity of the record cancellation. The COA relied on a 1992 COA decision and a 1927 NC Supreme Court case.

The COA acknowledged that the Fourth Circuit had read NC law differently; the Fourth Circuit, in 1995, had articulated "the following rule of North Carolina law: a subsequent lien creditor with a properly recorded deed of trust enjoys priority, despite the unauthorized cancellation of a prior deed of trust, if the subsequent creditor obtains its deed of trust after the cancellation has occurred, in reliance on the cancellation's validity, and without knowledge that the cancellation was unauthorized." The COA concluded that the Fourth Circuit was relying on dicta from a NC Supreme Court decision.

Full post as published by North Carolina Appellate Blog on February 05, 2008 (boomark / email).

Related Law Blog Posts

Search Blog Directory:

Deeds Designating Grantee as a Trustee Sufficient to Pass Title to Trust
The Florida Supreme court has ruled affirmatively on the question presented to it. Whether, under Florida Statutes section 689.07(1) as it existed before its 2004 amendment, this Deed??which is a recorded real estate conveyance deed to a named trustee of a private express trust identified in the deed by name and date, and contains other language referring to the unrecorded trust agreement, the settlors, and the beneficiaries??conveys only legal title to the property in trust to the grantee as trustee...

A deed designating the trust as the grantee is sufficient to pass legal title to the trustee
Prior state law provided that a deed that simply added the words ?trustee? or ?as trustee? to the name of the grantee conveyed to the grantee a fee simple estate unless the contrary intention appeared on the face of the...

Contract for Deed Cancellation in Minnesota: Can Bankruptcy Stop It
In Minnesota, the purchase of a home is most commonly financed by obtaining a mortgage, but it can also be accomplished by means of a contract for deed.� This is usually done by a buyer whose credit rating is too poor to qualify for a mortgage...

Fee Increase for Recording Documents in West Virginia
(Special contribution by Michael Sankey of BRB Publications, Inc.) Effective June 8, 2008, the recording fee for each document recorded in West Virginia recording offices will increase by $5...

Can I "undo" or cancel a deed that is already recorded
In Florida, if the wording of your current deed has consequences that you did not intend, you may want to consider a corrective deed. Please consult an Florida Estate Planning Lawyer , title company or other real estate professional to help you prepare your corrective deed...

How to trandfer property and keep your Homestead Exemption and SOH Intact
Are there other ways of transferring my property for estate planning that will not disturb my Homestead Exemption or SOH Cap? Two methods of transferring your property will, in most cases, keep your Homestead Exemption and SOH intact: reserve a Life Estate for yourself or transfer your property to your trust...

Search Blog Directory: