Home -> Law Blog Directory -> Academic Blogs -> Jurisdynamics
(866) 635-2689 for Personal Injury or (866) 635-9402 for Criminal Defense
Find a Local Lawyer
Divorce (866) 635-6190
Personal Injury (866) 635-2689
Criminal Defense (866) 635-9402
Academic
: JurisdynamicsAppointments with disaster: Binational arbitral review under the United-States-Canada Free Trade Agreement
By Jim Chen
I continue to post old, even ancient, papers to my SSRN page. This paper has reached its twentieth anniversary:
The United States-Canada Free Trade Agreement (FTA) of 1989 guaranteed free trade between the United States and its largest trading partner. One aspect of the treaty provoked intense constitutional scrutiny in the United States. The FTA requires binding binational arbitral review of antidumping and countervailing duty orders issued by the administrative agencies of each nation. This article argues that the FTA violates Article III and the Appointments Clause of the United States Constitution. The FTA offends the separation of powers. The FTA not only threatens the integrity of the federal judiciary but also undermines the strict procedures for appointing officers of the United States. The FTA violates Article III by deviating from the recognized methods for exerting federal adjudicatory power. The FTA's system for the appointment of arbitrators neither complies with the Appointments Clause nor satisfies an exception allowing the federal government to delegate its authority to persons who are not officers of the United States.
Jim Chen, Appointments with Disaster: The Unconstitutionality of Binational Arbitral Review Under the United States-Canada Free Trade Agreement, 49 Wash. & Lee L. Rev. 1455 (1992), available for download at http://ssrn.com/abstract=2050646.
Full post as published by Jurisdynamics on May 03, 2012 (boomark / email).
April 2009 Surface Trade with Canada and Mexico Fell 33.1 Percent from April 2008
News release: "Trade using surface transportation between the United States and its North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) partners Canada...
North American Surface Trade Numbers for March 2009
New release: "Trade using surface transportation between the United States and its North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) partners Canada...
Submissions on Canada-EU Trade Deal: Canadian Generic Pharma Assoc. Wants IP Out
Continuing the review of submissions to DFAIT regarding the Canada-EU Trade Agreement, the Canadian Generic Pharmaceutical Association warned against the inclusion of any intellectual property provisions: The very fact that both Canada and EU have robust IP systems in place should be a sufficient basis on which to enhance and expand our existing trade relationship...
Canada's Organic Trade Association supports Organic Equivalent Agreement
From Canadian Business.com The Organic Trade Association in Canada (OTA) responded in support of the announcement that Canada and the United States have signed an equivalency agreement allowing organic products to be traded between the two countries...
WHEAT AND TRADE: A Sad Day For U.S. Wheat Growers:
At last, sadly, the day has come and gone whe
WHEAT AND TRADE: A Sad Day For U.S. Wheat Growers: At last, sadly, the day has come and gone when the United States government has ignored the rational pleas of its citizens and businesses and handed an unnecessary advantage to countries that compete with us in world trade...
Is the IFPI Obstructing Free Trade to Pressure Canada into Copyright Reform
How far are the copyright lobbyists willing to go to bully Canada into copyright reform? It appears as though the copyright industry is now attempting to obstruct a free trade agreement between Canada and the European Union just for the purpose of getting their copyright laws into Canada...
Prenuptial Agreements
Make an Airtight Prenuptial Agreement
Trade Secrets
Former execs are hit with doctrine of inevitable disclosure.
Uniform Pre-marital Agreement Act
Standard Prenuptial Law
Parody is a Protected Form of Speech
Targets of criticism seek to shut down Internet sites that poke fun
Recall of TYLENOL 8 Hour Caplets 50 Count Sold in The United States and Puerto Rico
TYLENOL 8 Hour Caplets 50 Count One Lot Recalled in US and Puerto Rico
ValueClick
allegedly violated consumer protection laws by promising ‘free’ goods that where not actually free.
United Airlines Discriminates Against Blind Passengers
United Airlines Discriminates Against Blind Passengers
Train Crash
25 Dead, 135 Injured in LA Rail Disaster
Trade Secrets
Razorsight agreed to pay $4.5 million settlement in infringement lawsuit.
Newspaper Publisher
Star Tribune must pay St. Paul Pioneer Press a $3.8 million trade secrets act violations settlement.

The United States-Canada Free Trade Agreement (FTA) of 1989 guaranteed free trade between the United States and its largest trading partner. One aspect of the treaty provoked intense constitutional scrutiny in the United States. The FTA requires binding binational arbitral review of antidumping and countervailing duty orders issued by the administrative agencies of each nation. This article argues that the FTA violates Article III and the Appointments Clause of the United States Constitution. The FTA offends the separation of powers. The FTA not only threatens the integrity of the federal judiciary but also undermines the strict procedures for appointing officers of the United States. The FTA violates Article III by deviating from the recognized methods for exerting federal adjudicatory power. The FTA's system for the appointment of arbitrators neither complies with the Appointments Clause nor satisfies an exception allowing the federal government to delegate its authority to persons who are not officers of the United States.







